top of page
Search

Assessment of the Immigration Oversight Act on Alberta’s Visitor Economy

Misalignment is building between the Government of Alberta's macroeconomic objectives and its emerging regulatory framework. While the province’s Higher Ground Strategy targets a doubling of tourism revenues to $25 billion by 2035, the implementation mechanics of Bill 26, the Immigration Oversight Act, threaten to introduce significant operational risk across the sector.  With Alberta tourism employment hitting a new high water mark of over 270,000 jobs, persistent tourism skilled and unskilled workforce vacancies continue to threaten future growth potential.


To provide the ministry with rapid insights of how the Immigration Oversight Act will directly affect the business community, TIAA conducted an industry-wide impact and sentiment survey of hospitality and tourism operators between June 1 and June 8, 2026 receiving 100 responses. The findings reveal acute concerns around red tape, duplication of government efforts and significant impacts to the revenue viability of Alberta tourism businesses. Revealing that adding provincial layers to an already tightly regulated federal labour ecosystem risks choking capital yield, restricting operating hours, and eroding top-line revenue during peak cash-flow seasons.  

"My outfitting business relies on the ability to hire workers with exceptional skill with these same criteria being very limited in the Canadian talent pool. The inability to access workers would bankrupt my business." - ALBERTA OUTFITTER AND GUIDE

INDUSTRY CONSULTATION ON THE IMMIGRATION OVERSIGHT ACT
  • 65% of surveyed operators expressed explicit concern regarding the implementation of the Act, with half characterizing their concern as "high". Only 18% indicated any level of commercial support.  
  • 80% of respondents identified high or extreme operational risks stemming from administrative duplication between federal and provincial compliance frameworks.  
  • Two out of three surveyed employers state that forcing a provincial registration step prior to a federal Labour Market Impact Assessment (LMIA) submission introduces an unproductive bottleneck.

  • Over 40% of operators reported that processing delays under this model would force immediate reductions in service capacity and operating hours. 





One independent resort operator noted that out of 400 resumes received over three years for specialized instructor and supervisory positions, less than 5% were from Canadians.

STRUCTURAL CHALLENGES

The commercial utilization of any temporary economic immigration streams is a costly, time consuming measure of last resort which, in part, is driven by a deep structural labor paradox. Alberta’s tourism ecosystem is a massive employment engine, responsible for 1 in 10 jobs. Youth aged 15–24 comprise over 30% of this workforce, more than double the general economy average and continues to outperform all other sectors during the youth unemployment surge.  

However, macro data from HR Tourism Canada demonstrates the limitations of domestic youth supply: 71.9% of these student positions are part-time and highly seasonal. While vital for peak operational spikes, these workers naturally return to education cycles. They cannot backfill permanent, year-round, or specialized supervisory and culinary positions.  

Compounding the issue, broader structural shifts between 2022 and 2026; including the federal exclusion of hospitality from Post-Graduate Work Permits and the rollback of low-wage TFW caps from 20% to 10%, have already severely restricted predictable talent pipelines. In 2025, the job vacancy rate for accommodation and food services sat at 4.1%, tracking 46% higher than the average across all other economic sectors.  

“There are not enough Canadians to supply the workforce needed. Seasonal, student Canadians are not enough to fill the gap - we have year-round needs. To achieve tourism strategy, we need workers. - REGIONAL HOSPITALITY OPERATOR

This year's baseline allocations assigned to support the AAIP: Tourism and Hospitality Stream, amount to 2% of 6400 allocations. Only 150 nominations for 2026 is orders of magnitude below the actual labour requirements of the industry. Current provincial allocations are mathematically insufficient to satisfy the structural labour gaps needed to hit the province's own Higher Ground Tourism Growth Strategy.

The systemic contraction of the temporary-to-permanent labor pipeline via the AAIP has created immediate, measurable friction points for operators. Long-serving, highly trained international workers who have contributed years of taxes and economic service to Alberta are being cut off from viable provincial permanent residency pathways, resulting in an acute drain of skilled and semi-skilled talent.

"The federal government has already implemented stricter rules with regards to immigration. The province should be helping ease the burden, not adding to it. “ - RURAL ACCOMODATION OPERATOR

PROTECTING COMPETITIVENESS

Alberta's world-class tourism operators firmly support aggressive enforcement against non-compliant, fraudulent actors who compromise industry integrity. However, from a commercial perspective, building a parallel provincial bureaucracy is an inefficient allocation of regulatory resources.  

The federal framework already imposes severe, business-ending penalties for non-compliance, including:

  • Absolute revocation of all active LMIAs.  

  • Permanent operational bans from the TFW and International Mobility Programs.  

  • Monetary fines scaling from $100,000 to $1 million annually. 


INDUSTRY RECOMMENDATIONS

TIAA’s formal submission to the Ministry of Jobs, Economy, Trade and Immigration emphasizes that any new provincial oversight must minimize the significant risk of top-line industry revenue destruction while meeting compliance objectives.


TIAA respectfully recommended that the Government of Alberta:

 

  • Harmonize all provincial application steps and data compliance with existing, functioning federal frameworks to avoid costly delays, introduction of new red tape and administrative duplication. 

  • Phase in changes gradually and protect current visa workers and existing permits during the transition.

  • Establish and publish provincial processing timelines, offer plain-language guidance, and scale registration fees proportionately to the size of the operation.

  • Resume full public reporting on occupational selections and sectoral allocations under the Alberta Advantage Immigration Program to allow businesses to accurately plan and allocate seasonal resources. 

  • Direct and coordinate enforcement resources toward recruiters, consultants, and underground operations utilizing contract or under-the-table labour and illegal business practices such as non-compliant short-term rentals or ghost kitchens located in residential districts.

  • Request that the Government of Canada extend Alberta's access to temporary rural employer measures under the TFW program, enabling employers outside census metropolitan areas to retain current workforce and access the temporary 15% low-wage cap.


The above recommendations align directly with the Government of Alberta's own Higher Ground Provincial Tourism Growth Strategy, specifically Pillar 3: People & Careers, which mandates practical policies to address immediate labour shortages and build long-term workforce capacity. Practical immigration supports, alongside industry-led training and apprenticeship pathways, are foundational to this strategy.

Higher Ground Tourism Growth Strategy (2024) Develop and implement policies that address short- and long-term labour challenges for employers, enabling communities to retain and attract residents.

To achieve the province's objective of doubling tourism revenues to $25 billion by 2035, our entire hospitality and visitor ecosystem requires stable, predictable access to international labour to maintain service levels and meet growing global demand

 

Abrupt and drastic policy alterations, such as those experienced during the Covid-19 Pandemic can instantly disrupt the labour market's ability to meet demand. This causes job vacancies to skyrocket, leaves operators struggling to keep their doors open, and fuels upward inflationary pressures at the exact moment the economy requires stability.


Alberta's tourism and hospitality operators fully support protecting vulnerable workers, punishing non-compliance and strengthening the integrity of our immigration system alongside growing our economy. The most effective framework under the Immigration Oversight Act will be practical, coordinated, and highly responsive to the province's tourism labour realities.  Ensuring these new regulations do not conflict with the government's explicit commitment to reducing red tape and improving provincial business competitiveness is an industry priority. A balanced approach is needed.

Download TIAA's June 12, 2026 Letter to Minister Joseph Schow and Survey Results below:






bottom of page